- Open Access
Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma of the pelvis: clinical outcomes and current treatment
Clinical Sarcoma Research volume 8, Article number: 23 (2018)
Dedifferentiated chondrosarcomas (CS) are a high-grade variant of CS that confers a 5-year survival of around 10–24%. Dedifferentiated CS arising from the pelvis confers an even worse prognosis.
(1) What is the prognosis of patients with dedifferentiated CS of the pelvis? (2) Do wide margins or type of surgical intervention influence outcome? (3) Does the use of adjuvant therapy affect outcome?
Patients were retrospectively reviewed from a prospectively collated musculoskeletal oncology database from 1995 to 2016. Thirty-one cases of dedifferentiated CS arising from the pelvis were included. Wide margins were defined as greater than 4 mm. The mean age was 55.6 years (range 33 to 76 years) and there were 19 males (61.3%) and 12 females (38.7%).
The disease presented at a locally or systemically advanced stage in 13 patients (41.9%). Eighteen patients (58.1%) underwent surgery with curative intent. Overall survival at 12 months was 15.4% for patients treated with palliative intent and 50% for those treated with surgery. In the surgical group, there were higher rates of disease-free survival in patients who underwent hindquarter amputation and those who received wide surgical margins (p = 0.047 and p = 0.019, respectively). Those who underwent hindquarter amputation were more likely to achieve wide margins (p = 0.05). Time to recurrent disease (local or systemic) was always less than 24 months. No hindquarter amputation for recurrent disease resulted in disease-free survival. No patient who received adjuvant therapy for palliative or recurrent disease had disease control.
Pelvic dedifferentiated CS often presents at an advanced local or systemic stage and confers a poor prognosis. Achieving wide surgical margins (> 4 mm) provided the highest rate of long-term disease-free survival. Failing to achieve wide margins results in rapid disease recurrence, conferring deleterious consequences.
Chondrosarcoma (CS) is a rare malignant bone tumour composed of cartilage matrix-producing cells. It is the second most common primary bone sarcoma with an incidence of 1 in 200,000/year. It may arise in the medullary cavity of bone (central CS) or secondary to a malignant transformation of a benign cartilage tumour . The most important factor for guiding management and prognosis is determining the histological grade of the tumour. There is a high degree of inter-observer variability when determining histological grade . Dedifferentiated CS is defined as one area of a lower grade cartilage tumour that lies directly adjacent to an area of high-grade non-cartilaginous sarcoma . Only 10% of all CS dedifferentiate, which is fortunate as these high-grade tumours are associated with a 5-year survival of around 10–24% [1, 4, 5].
Chondrosarcomas, in general, are resistant to chemotherapy and conventional radiotherapy. Occasionally, short-term local control can be achieved but has no proven benefit on distant spread or overall survival [6,7,8]. Consequently, surgery remains the mainstay of treatment for dedifferentiated CS. Dedifferentiated CS arising from the pelvis is known to be a negative prognostic factor, further lowering the survival rate [9, 10]. For this disease, there is limited evidence defining the presenting disease stage, accuracy of pre-operative diagnosis and treatment factors influencing outcome .
Current treatment for pelvic dedifferentiated CS consists of either palliative, limb-salvage through pelvic resection with or without reconstruction, or limb-sacrifice with hindquarter amputation [5, 6]. Tumour excision with wide margins should provide the best prognosis although this is often difficult due to the proximity of vital structures. This association and the probability of achieving wide margins with limb-salvage has yet to be described in pelvic dedifferentiated CS.
We report our experience with dedifferentiated CS of the pelvis including diagnosis, survival and surgical outcomes. The questions we attempted to answer in this study were; (1) what is the prognosis of patients with dedifferentiated CS of the pelvis? (2) Do wide margins or type of surgical intervention influence outcome in patients for attempted curative resection? (3) Does the use of adjuvant therapy affect outcome?
Patients and methods
A retrospective review was conducted of a prospectively maintained database to identify patients with a histological diagnosis of dedifferentiated CS managed at a single tertiary musculoskeletal oncology centre. Minimum follow-up was 12 months or until death. 116 patients were diagnosed with dedifferentiated CS between 1995 and 2016.
31 patients were identified with pelvic dedifferentiated CS. They had a mean age of 55.6 years (range 33 to 76 years). There were 19 males (61.3%) and 12 females (38.7%). The ilium (P1) was involved in 51.6% (16/31) of tumours. 48.4% of tumours (15/31) involved the periacetabular (P2) region either in isolation or in combination with other pelvic regions (Fig. 1).
Local tumour staging comprised of plain radiography and magnetic resonance imaging (MRI). Distant staging comprised of chest computed tomography (CT) and bone scintigraphy. All patients were managed by a specialist sarcoma multidisciplinary team (MDT). Histological diagnosis was based on biopsy material and reviewed by a specialist sarcoma pathologist prior to surgical treatment. In 11/18 patients (61.1%) undergoing surgical resection the histological diagnosis of a dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma was made on the biopsy material pre-operatively. In the remaining seven patients (38.9%) pre-operative biopsy failed to accurately grade the tumour when compared to the post resection histology. Of these seven patients, three had a biopsy that suggested a low-grade CS, two a high-grade CS and in two, a spindle cell sarcoma with no cartilaginous elements (Table 1).
Wide margins, the aim of surgery, were defined as greater than 4 mm on final pathological specimen analysis . Indications for hindquarter amputation (HQA) were involvement of two of the following three structures: sciatic nerve, hip joint, external iliac vessels or where it was deemed the safest way to achieve wide margins (Figs. 2a, b, 3a–c). Chemotherapy and radiotherapy was guided by oncologists on an individualised basis to attempt systemic or local short-term tumour control.
Patients were divided into palliative or surgical treatment groups. 13 patients (41.9%) were in the palliative group. Patients were not offered surgery due to either advanced metastatic disease (in 10 patients), the tumour was deemed unresectable (entire hemipelvis involvement, including the sacrum and sciatic notch), too medically unfit for surgery or died during neoadjuvant chemotherapy (one patient each) (Table 2). Patients in the surgical group were analysed according to the surgical procedure and surgical margins.
18 patients (58.1%) underwent attempted curative treatment by surgery. 13 patients underwent limb-salvage surgery (LSS) and five HQA. None of the patients in the surgical group had metastases at the time of diagnosis. For those treated by LSS, six (46.2%) had internal hemipelvectomies without reconstruction, three (23.1%) had a stemmed acetabular prosthesis (“ice-cream” cone), three (23.1%) had custom implants and one (7.7%) had combined internal hemipelvectomy and a proximal femoral replacement.
One patient died from a post-operative cardiac arrest and another suffered a periprosthetic infection which was successfully treated through debridement, implant retention and antibiotics.
Statistical analysis was performed using R and deducer statistical software packages, and considered statistically significant at p < 0.05. Analysis of local recurrence-free survival (LRFS), metastasis-free survival (MFS), disease-free (DFS) and overall survival (OS) was performed using the Kaplan–Meier survival method with 95% confidence intervals (CI). To assess the effect of different factors on survival outcomes, the Cox proportional hazards (PH) model was used.
41.9% of patients (n = 13) were considered incurable by resection of the primary tumour and were offered palliative treatment only. In this group, the median survival was 3 months (IQR 2 to 8 months); two patients (15.4%) in this group survived beyond 12 months. The longest survival (34 months), was seen in a patient treated with palliative radiotherapy alone as they were unfit for ablative surgery.
Of the patients (n = 18, 58.1%) who underwent attempted curative resection with wide margins, the OS at 12 months was 50.0% (95% CI 31.5%–79.4%), at 36 months was 29.2% (95% CI 13.4%–63.4%) (Fig. 4a). At 12 months, the LRFS and MFS were 56.1% (95% CI 36.1%–87.2%) and 47.2% (95% CI 28.6%–78.1%), respectively. At 36 months, the LRFS and MFS were 32.7% (95% CI 15.2%–70.2%) and 28.3% (95% CI 13.0%–61.7%), respectively. The mean time to local recurrence and metastasis was 7.5 months (range 2 to 20 months) and 7.4 months (range 0.5 to 24 months), respectively. There were five patients with long-term DFS (27.8%) after undergoing surgery with curative intent. There was no difference in age (p = 0.842), size (p = 0.191) or proportion of isolated P1 area tumours (p = 0.260) between survivors and those with disease recurrence or death.
Limb-salvage versus amputation
Of the five patients who underwent HQA, three (60%) are still alive with no evidence of disease at 12, 51 and 121 months follow-up. All three had wide margins of excision. The remaining two patients (40%) had marginal and intralesional excision margins and both developed local recurrence (4 and 14 months, respectively), metastases (3 and 13 months, respectively) and died (4 and 33 months, respectively) (Table 1).
Of the 13 patients who underwent LSS, three patients remain alive at a mean 62.3 months since operation, of which, two have no evidence of disease, at 100 and 63 months, one had a wide and the other a marginal excision, respectively. The remaining 10 patients have died (one dying in perioperative period from cardiac arrest). The LRFS and MFS at last follow-up was 22.2% (95% CI 6.7%–73.8%) and 16.8% (95% CI 4.7%–59.4%), respectively. The mean time to local recurrence was 7.1 months (range 2 to 20 months), mean time to metastases was 7.3 months (range 0 to 24 months) and the mean time to death was 8.7 months (range 0 to 29 months).
The DFS for the LSS cohort was 15.4% (95% CI 4.3%–55.0%) and 60% for the HQA group. The DFS was significantly greater in patients who underwent HQA (p = 0.047) (Fig. 4b). There was no significant difference between groups in time to local recurrence or metastases (p = 0.776 and p = 0.914, respectively).
90% of patients with recurrence developed local recurrence and metastases synchronously (maximum 4 months between events). One patient developed local recurrence at 2 months with metastases detected at 11 months.
3/13 (23%) patients in the LSS group underwent secondary HQA for locally recurrent disease. The mean time from surgery to additional operation was 11.7 months. A wide resection margin at subsequent HQA was achieved in two patients and a marginal margin in one. One patient died from a complication of the amputation, one lived an additional 9 months and the other remains alive with local and systemic disease 21 months following HQA.
The type of surgery significantly affected the margins achieved. HQA achieved wide margins more frequently than LSS (p = 0.05) (Table 3).
Disease-free survival was greater in patients who received wide resection margins (p = 0.019). Of the five patients presumed cured, with no evidence of disease at last follow-up, four (80%) had wide resection margins, the last had marginal margins. Overall, 80% of patients who had wide margins were cured, 16.7% of patients with marginal margins were cured and no patients with intralesional margins were disease-free at last follow-up (Table 1 and Fig. 4c).
Chemotherapy and radiotherapy
Chemotherapy was not used routinely, but was used palliatively or postoperatively following the development of recurrent disease. In most cases where chemotherapy was used, it consisted of cisplatin and doxorubicin. One patient had neoadjuvant chemotherapy, 4 cycles of cisplatin and doxorubicin, after the initial biopsy suggested the diagnosis of spindle cell sarcoma. Following resection, dedifferentiated CS was confirmed. This patient had < 10% necrosis, a marginal margin and is alive at 63 months following surgery (being the only survivor with a marginal margin).
Radiotherapy was used palliatively or for management of local recurrence. The radiotherapy dose ranged from 30 to 70 Grays depending on adjacent anatomical structures, tumour site and size. No patients who had radiotherapy survived.
In all chondrosarcomas, survival correlates with histological grade, and the dedifferentiated CS subtype is known to confer the worst prognosis [1, 9, 10, 12]. In accordance with other studies, dedifferentiated CS has a peak incidence in the 6th decade of life, a male predilection, and a male-to-female ratio of 3:2 observed in our series [12,13,14].
Dedifferentiated CS has been associated with a poor prognosis . The best chance of cure was linked to excision of the tumour with clear margins . Achieving clear margins is much more difficult in the pelvis, even with HQA. The role of chemotherapy and radiotherapy is largely palliative [7, 8, 15,16,17,18]. The presenting clinical scenario and treatment of pelvic dedifferentiated CS has not been specifically examined previously, however, data extrapolated from previous studies clearly reveals pelvic disease confers a dreadful prognosis (Table 4) [5, 9, 10, 12, 19, 20].
In the present study concerning dedifferentiated CS of the pelvis, 42% of patients presented with such advanced disease that surgery was not a viable treatment option. Unsurprisingly, patients able to undergo surgery with curative intent had greater overall survival than the palliative group. The only long-term survivors with no evidence of disease (16.1% of the cohort) underwent attempted curative surgical resection with wide or marginal margins.
Patients who underwent primary HQA had higher rates of disease-free survival than those who underwent LSS, 60% vs 15.4%, respectively. This likely correlated to the higher rates of wide margins achieved with HQA. In patients who had LSS, 66.7% had local recurrence and in the those who did not develop local recurrence, two are long term survivors and the other two died at 3 and 4 months. Other studies of predominantly non-dedifferentiated pelvic CS have revealed satisfactory margins can be achieved with limb-salvage [6, 12, 13]. However, one study identified a significantly higher chance of obtaining a clear margin with amputation . Our data suggests that wide margins are more achievable with HQA, which was translated into improved local control and survival. The primary operation to consider in those with dedifferentiated CS should be a HQA with wide margins to offer patients the best chance of cure. In this series, none of the three patients who had HQA with wide margins died, compared to only three survivors in the 15 patients who had any other combination of surgery and margin type.
Obtaining a wide margin has been reported to be a positive prognostic indicator for non-dedifferentiated CS [11, 14, 22]. However, it remains unclear whether achieving a wide margin around dedifferentiated CS impacts local recurrence [12,13,14, 23]. In our series, there was an 80% chance of achieving disease cure when wide margins, greater than 4 mm, were obtained. Of the five patients who were completely disease-free at last follow-up, four had a wide margin and the other a marginal margin. There were no long-term survivors in those with intralesional tumour resection.
Another issue with pelvic dedifferentiated CS, reflecting the tumour heterogeneity and large volume, is that 7 of the 18 curative patients did not have the correct diagnosis on initial biopsy. Three of these patients were thought to have low-grade CS and LSS was carried out with very close margins. Although one died postoperatively the other two both developed recurrent disease at 2 months. This highlights the importance of obtaining wide margins in any pelvic CS. Four of the five patients who were disease-free at last follow-up had accurate pre-operative biopsies. Saifuddin et al. have suggested taking biopsies from areas of reduced signal intensity on T2-weighted MRI may result in higher detection rates of dedifferentiated CS .
For isolated local recurrence of dedifferentiated CS treated with amputation, no patients achieved a cure or long-term survival (mean survival = 9.7 months). LR and metastases occurred synchronously in 90%. A study reporting surgical outcomes for recurrent CS of the pelvis also showed no overall survival advantage when treating recurrent high-grade CS tumours . Therefore, the priority should be initial curative resection to reduce the chance of recurrence as rapid disease progression, with subsequent death can be anticipated.
In our series, one of the notable findings was that all recurrent disease, whether local or systemic arose within 24 months. This is likely a reflection of the extremely aggressive nature of this tumour. A high chance of cure can be expected if a patient lacks any evidence of disease after 24 months follow-up. A short time to recurrent disease was also evident in previous studies (Table 4).
We found no benefit for chemotherapy or radiotherapy used in a palliative setting, reaffirming the belief that chemotherapy and radiotherapy are ineffective at controlling dedifferentiated CS .
The limitations to this series are that the data is based on a retrospective analysis from a single institution, with inherent selection bias both in those treated surgically and in the type of surgical procedure. This study was not able to analyse whether having wide margins from the dedifferentiated component of the tumour or if having a small proportion of dedifferentiation within the tumour was associated with increased survival as this was not routinely reported by pathologists, however, these would be important areas to research in the future. Additionally, the sample size was small, reflecting the rarity of this disease, therefore whether amputation is truly superior at achieving radical section margins cannot be proven, and a larger multi-institutional review would help clarify this.
Dedifferentiated CS of the pelvis confers a poor prognosis. 12-month survival is 15.4% in those treated palliatively and 55.6% when treated with curative intent. It is a particularly aggressive disease, presenting at an advanced, inoperable state in almost half of patients. The factors that influenced disease cure were achieving a wide surgical margin (greater than 4 mm), which was more common with HQA. Margins less than 4 mm have a very high risk of local recurrence and death. HQA for local recurrence did not result in disease control and 90% of disease recurrence occurred synchronously. Obtaining the correct pre-operative diagnosis is also an important factor. We recommend early surgery with the widest possible margins to optimise chances for long-term survival.
local recurrence-free survival
Giuffrida AY, Burgueno JE, Koniaris LG, Gutierrez JC, Duncan R, Scully Sean P. Chondrosarcoma in the United States (1973 to 2003): an analysis of 2890 cases from the SEER database. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2009;91(5):1063–72.
Skeletal Lesions Interobserver Correlation among Expert Diagnosticians (SLICED) Study Group. Reliability of histopathologic and radiologic grading of cartilaginous neoplasms in long bones. J Bone Joint Surg. 2007;89(10):2113–23.
Bovée JVMG, Cleton-Jansen A-M, Rosenberg C, Taminiau AHM, Cornelisse CJ, Hogendoorn PCW. Molecular genetic characterization of both components of a dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma, with implications for its histogenesis. J Pathol. 1999;189:454–62.
Bindiganavile S, Han I, Yun JY, Kim HS. Long-term outcome of chondrosarcoma: a single institutional experience. Cancer Res Treat. 2015;47(4):897–903.
Frassica FJ, Unni KK, Beabout JW, Sim FH. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma A report of the clinicopathological features and treatment of 78 cases. J Bone Joint Surg. 1986;68(8):1197–205.
Dickey ID, Rose PS, Fuchs B, Wold LE, Okuno SH, Sim FH, Scully SP. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma. J Bone Joint Surg Am. 2004;86(11):2412–8.
Italiano A, Mir O, Cioffi A, Palmerini E, Piperno-Neumann S, Perrin S, Chaigneau L, Penel N, Duffaud F, Kurtz JE, Collard O, Bertucci F, Bompas E, Le Cesne A, Maki RG, Ray Coquard I, Blay JY. Advanced chondrosarcomas: role of chemotherapy and survival. Ann Oncol. 2013;24(11):2916–22.
van Maldegem AM, Gelderblom H, Palmerini E, Dijkstra SD, Gambarotti M, Ruggieri P, Nout RA, van de Sande MA, Ferrari C, Ferrari S, Bovée JV, Picci P. Outcome of advanced, unresectable conventional central chondrosarcoma. Cancer. 2014;120(20):3159–64.
Liu C, Xi Y, Li M, Jiao Q, Zhang H, Yang Q, Yao W. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma: radiological features, prognostic factors and survival statistics in 23 patients. PLoS ONE. 2017;12(3):e0173665.
Grimer RJ, Gosheger G, Taminiau A, Biau D, Matejovsky Z, Kollender Y, San-Julian M, Gherlinzoni F, Ferrari C. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma: prognostic factors and outcome from a European group. Eur J Cancer. 2007;43(14):2060–5.
Stevenson JD, Laitinen MK, Parry MC, Sumathi V, Grimer RJ, Jeys LM. The role of surgical margins in chondrosarcoma. Eur J Surg Oncol. 2018;44(9):1412–8.
Mavrogenis AF, Angelini A, Drago G, Merlino B, Ruggieri P. Survival analysis of patients with chondrosarcomas of the pelvis. J Surg Oncol. 2013;108(1):19–27.
Deloin X, Dumaine V, Biau D, Karoubi M, Babinet A, Tomeno B, Anract P. Pelvic chondrosarcomas: surgical treatment options. Orthop Traumatol. 2009;95(6):393–401.
Littrell LA, Wenger DE, Wold LE, Bertoni F, Unni KK, White LM, Kandel R, Sundaram M. Radiographic, CT, and MR imaging features of dedifferentiated chondrosarcomas: a retrospective review of 174 de novo cases. RadioGraphics. 2004;24(5):1397–409.
Kostine M, Cleven AH, De Miranda NF, Italiano A, Cleton-Jansen AM, Bovée JV. Analysis of PD-L1, T-cell infiltrate and HLA expression in chondrosarcoma indicates potential for response to immunotherapy specifically in the dedifferentiated subtype. Mod Pathol. 2016;29(9):1028–37.
van Oosterwijk JG, Meijer D, Van Ruler MA, van den Akker BE, Oosting J, Krenács T, Picci P, Flanagan AM, Liegl-Atzwanger B, Leithner A, Athanasou N, Daugaard S, Hogendoorn PC, Bovée JV. Screening for potential targets for therapy in mesenchymal, clear cell, and dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma reveals Bcl-2 family members and TGFβ as potential targets. Am J Pathol. 2013;182(4):1347–56.
Uhl M, Mattke M, Welzel T, Oelmann J, Habl G, Jensen A, Ellerbrock M, Haberer T, Herfarth K, Debus J. High control rate in patients with chondrosarcoma of the skull base after carbon ion therapy: first report of long-term results. Cancer. 2014;120(10):1579–85.
Weber DC, Malyapa R, Albertini F, Bolsi A, Kliebsch U, Walser M, Pica A, Combescure C, Lomax A, Schneider R. Long term outcomes of patients with skull-base low-grade chondrosarcoma and chordoma patients treated with pencil beam scanning proton therapy. Radiother Oncol. 2016;120(1):169–74.
Weber KL, Pring ME, Sim FH. Treatment and outcome of recurrent pelvic chondrosarcoma. Clin Orthop Related Res. 2002;397:19–28.
Sheth DS, Yasko AW, Johnson ME, Ayala AG, Murray JA, Romsdahl MM. Chondrosarcoma of the pelvis: prognostic factors for 67 patients treated with definitive surgery. Cancer. 1996;78(4):745–50.
Donati D, El Ghoneimy A, Bertoni F, Di Bella A, Mercuri M. Surgical treatment and outcome of conventional pelvic chondrosarcoma. J Bone Joint Surg. 2005;87(11):1527–30.
Lee FY, Mankin HJ, Fondren G, Gebhardt MC, Springfield DS, Rosenberg AE, Jennings LC. Chondrosarcoma of bone. J Bone Joint Surg. 1999;81(3):326–38.
Bus MPA, Campanacci DA, Albergo JI, Leithner A, van de Sande MAJ, Gaston CL, Caff G, Mettelsiefen J, Capanna R, Tunn PU, Jeys LM, Dijkstra PDS. Conventional primary central chondrosarcoma of the pelvis: prognostic factors and outcome of surgical treatment in 162 patients. J Bone Joint Surg. 2018;100(4):316–25.
Saifuddin A, Mann BS, Mahroof S, Pringle JAS, Briggs TWR, Cannon SR. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma: use of MRI to guide needle biopsy. Clin Radiol. 2004;59(3):268–72.
JRL: Writing and preparing the manuscript and tables, SE: Data collection and manuscript editing, JDS: Data collection and manuscript editing, MP: Manuscript editing, LMJ: Idea conception and manuscript editing, RJG: Idea conception and manuscript editing. All authors read and approved the final manuscript.
Each author certifies that he or she has no commercial associations (e.g. consultancies, stock ownership, equity interest, patent/licensing arrangements, etc.) that might pose a conflict of interest in connection with the submitted article. On behalf of all authors, the corresponding author states that there is no competing interests.
Availability of data and materials
Due to the rarity of this disease, any data that may possibly expose patient identity is excluded and not to be shared for confidentiality purposes.
Consent for publication
All authors have consented for the manuscript to be published.
Ethical approval and consent to participate
There was no explicit ethical review committee approval required for the undertaking of this study. All data collected was done so in a confidential manner and in accordance with the regulations of the US Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA).
There was no funding or financial support utilized to carry out this research.
Springer Nature remains neutral with regard to jurisdictional claims in published maps and institutional affiliations.
Rights and permissions
Open Access This article is distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution 4.0 International License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribution, and reproduction in any medium, provided you give appropriate credit to the original author(s) and the source, provide a link to the Creative Commons license, and indicate if changes were made. The Creative Commons Public Domain Dedication waiver (http://creativecommons.org/publicdomain/zero/1.0/) applies to the data made available in this article, unless otherwise stated.
About this article
Cite this article
Lex, J.R., Evans, S., Stevenson, J.D. et al. Dedifferentiated chondrosarcoma of the pelvis: clinical outcomes and current treatment. Clin Sarcoma Res 8, 23 (2018). https://doi.org/10.1186/s13569-018-0110-1